Honolulu Advertiser
Tuesday, November 14, 1995
By Mark Matsunaga
Hawaiian sovereignty activist Dennis "Bumpy" Kanahele last night
repented for his past aggression, drew endorsements from other Hawaiian
leaders, then won a court order freeing him from prison.
"My past is my past. I was hard head before, " Kanahele, head
of the self-proclaimed Nation of Hawaii, told federal Judge David Ezra.
"Whatever it takes to patch things and make things work, you got my
word."
Leaders from such organizations as the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, state
Hawaiian Sovereignty Elections Council and Ka Lahui Hawai'i assured the
judge that Kanahele is neither a danger to this community not a flight risk.
They testified he should be released on bail pending trail in January on
charges that he harbored convicted tax protester Nathan Brown and foiled
two attempts to arrest Brown last year.
A half-dozen church leaders also were on hand to testify.
After a 2 1/2-hour hearing, Ezra ruled that Kanahele can be released as
early as today to the Miller Hale "halfway house" on the slopes
of Punchbowl until his new trial.
Kanahele will be required to spend his nights there, but will be free to
go out during the days. Ezra cited the risk of danger of "overzealous
supporters" and ordered Kanahele to stay out of Waimanalo, where his
closest supporters have established a settlement on state land. The Nation
of Hawai'i calls it "Puuhonua (Refuge) Village;" federal officials
call it "a compound."
The state offered the facility to Kanahele and his followers last year,
in exchange for their ending a 15-month occupation of Kaupo and Makapuu
beach parks. The Nation of Hawaii claims several thousand members, who advocate
Hawaiian independence and contend that the federal and state governments
are occupying the Islands illegally.
Deemed a danger to the community and likely no-show for trial, Kanahele
has been held without bail since he was indicted and arrested on Aug. 2.
Kanahele stood trial on the charges last month, but that ended in a mistrial
because of the jury's deadlock and a juror's misconduct.
Yesterday he and his lawyer, Hayden Aluli, asked Ezra to reconsider holding
Kanahele without bail.
Kanahele said that he's been pushing Hawaiian independence, but believed
it was his right under the U.S. Constitution: "I thought you could
speak without getting in trouble."
But he told Ezra, "Today I understand that it cannot be done the way
I like 'em done. . . . I think I was put in prison for understand that I
might have been too aggressive."
Kanahele, 41, also mentioned that yesterday was his 21st wedding anniversary.
Aluli called seven people to the stand, and offered endorsements from many
others.
Among those who testified were OHA trustees A. Frenchy DeSota and Kina'u
Kamali'i as well as Hawaiian scholar Lilikala Kame'eleihiwa.
"We who grew up poor, who grew up in the street, who grew up rough,
sometimes we say rough things," said Kame'eleihiwa, a citizen of Ka
Lahui Hawai'i, a sovereignty group that has often clashed with Kanahele.
But she pointed out that during the 1986 Makapuu occupation that resulted
in Kanahele's conviction for threatening a policeman, no one was killed
or shot.
Office of Hawaiian Affairs trustee Kamali'i called Kanahele "passionate.
"Some people might take that as being violent," Kamali'i said.
When Ezra mentioned that Kanahele might have to pay his own rent at the
Miller Street halfway house or stay at Halawa until the federal government
could find the money, Aluli turned around and saw Kamali'i sitting behind
him. She immediately offered to put up $2,000 in personal funds to cover
Kanahele's costs.
DeSoto, who has know Kanahele since he was a child, promised Ezra that he
would return for his second trial.
"I swear to you, judge, on the lives of my children and my grandchildren
and my great-grandchildren, he will not run. He has given his word, and
his word is sacred," DeSoto said.
Ezra on his own came up with the notion of sending Kanahele to the Miller
Hale halfway house.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Les Osborne wanted Kanahele to remain in jail. He
said Kanahele's "antisocial dangerous conduct" has continued into
this year and argued that Kanahele "has no reason" to return to
court for his case.
But Aluli said Kanahele's supporters could post bail of up to $250,000 and
another $57,000 from the equity in Kanahele's Hawaiian Homes house.
Ezra said he wanted to balance Kanehele's rights with the safety of the
community and concerns by law enforcement officials.
The judge cited the time Kanahele has already been held without bail and
the initial mistrial.
Any further detention would not "serve any useful purpose," the
judge said.
Osborne said he was disappointed in Ezra's ruling.
"I sincerely hope he (Kanahele) doesn't disappoint the judge or the
people of this state." Advertiser Staff Writers Ann Botticelli and
Ken Kobayashi contributed to this report.
![]()
Return to the Nation
of Hawai`i Home Page, the News Articles Index,
or the Political Prisoner page